I did three interviews to test the expressiveness of the rough auras: one in person and two over the phone. I asked my participants to watch the 12 animated auras (above) and tell me how they interpreted them. Afterwards I explained my intended emotion and asked how I could change or improve them. In a nutshell, here is what I learned:

Things that work:

  1. Participants can sense the difference between negative and positive auras.
  2. The design is inviting and easily understood.
  3. Nonchalant was picked up on by all participants.
  4. Angry was understood by all.
  5. Sad was also understood by all.

Things that need improving:

  1. No one understood sarcastic and all thought it was not needed since it's the same as joking.
  2. No one understood awkward.
  3. Confused is not needed since people would likely express that with words.
  4. Tired looks too playful.
  5. Scared reads more as tired.

To see a full summary of my findings…


Posted
AuthorDavid Spears

Looking back at my process, I have arrived at a very experimental project and visual language: getting rid of the text bubble, using handmade elements and typography, and staining. According Raymond Loewy MAYA principle (most advanced yet acceptable) “the adult public’s taste is not necessarily ready to accept the logical solutions to their requirements if the solution implies too vast a departure from what they have been conditioned into accepting as the norm.” So I have to ask myself: Have i gone too far?

My original concept for weather looked very UI, flat, and exactly what you'd expect to see (Look A: Traditional). Through experimentation I combined line art weather elements with stains and simplifying the text bubble to a stroked rounded rectangle (Look B: Contemporary). More experimentation and refinement lead me to hand drawn weather elements with stains, eliminating the text bubble entirely, and combining expressive handwriting with digital typography (Look C: Experimental). Rather than making an subjective decision, I'll let my audience decide.


Posted
AuthorDavid Spears